ARFID and Trying New Foods: The Pros and Cons of “Just Try It”
“Just try it.”
For someone without Avoidant/Restrictive Food Intake Disorder (ARFID), this phrase might seem harmless. If you're unsure about a new hair product, someone might encourage you to try it. If you're hesitant about joining a sport, a friend might suggest trying it for a season. But when it comes to food, the words “just try it” can have a very different impact on someone with ARFID.
For individuals with ARFID, trying a new food may bring up intense anxiety, sensory discomfort, fear of choking or vomiting, disgust, or an overwhelming feeling that the food is unsafe. Something that seems simple to one person can feel incredibly difficult to another.
This raises an important question: Is it helpful to tell someone with ARFID to “just try” a new food?

The answer is not always straightforward. Trying new foods can be an important part of ARFID treatment and recovery, but how, when, and why we encourage someone to try matters.
Let's explore the pros and cons of “just try it” and how families, caregivers, and clinicians can better support individuals with ARFID as they work toward eating disorder recovery.
What Is ARFID, and Why Can Trying New Foods Be So Difficult?
Avoidant/Restrictive Food Intake Disorder (ARFID) is an eating disorder characterized by restrictive eating that can lead to nutritional deficiencies, inadequate energy intake, reliance on nutritional supplements, weight or growth concerns, or significant interference with daily life.
Unlike eating disorders primarily driven by concerns about body weight or shape, ARFID-related food avoidance may be associated with sensory sensitivities, fear of unpleasant consequences from eating, or a lack of interest in food.
For someone with ARFID, trying a new food may involve much more than deciding whether they like its taste. The food's smell, texture, appearance, temperature, or even the possibility of an unpleasant experience can trigger a significant response.
This is why encouragement to try new foods needs to be thoughtful, individualized, and supportive.
5 Things to Consider Before Asking Someone with ARFID to “Just Try It”
1. Understand What ARFID Is—and What It Isn't
Asking someone without ARFID to try an unfamiliar food generally does not cause the same mental, physical, or emotional response that it may cause for someone with ARFID.
Understanding this difference is essential to providing compassionate support.
Imagine a child attending a family gathering where a great-grandparent notices that the only food on the child's plate is a hot dog bun. The great-grandparent might say, “Why don't you just try this? You'll never know if you like it unless you try!”
The intention may be positive. Perhaps the great-grandparent wants to help the child eat a wider variety of foods. However, if that person does not understand ARFID or the child's individual challenges, the request may feel overwhelming, embarrassing, or invalidating.
The child may already be working hard to manage anxiety around food. Being unexpectedly asked to eat something unfamiliar, especially in front of other people, can add another layer of stress.
What helps instead?
Take time to understand ARFID, learn about the individual's specific food-related challenges, and consider your relationship with that person. A parent or clinician who understands the individual's recovery goals may approach food exploration differently than a relative who is unfamiliar with ARFID.
Understanding the person behind the food avoidance is an important first step.
2. Consider Your Tone and Attitude When Encouraging Someone to Try a Food
How we say something matters.
An exasperated “Just try it!” can communicate frustration, judgment, or a lack of understanding. In contrast, a calm and encouraging invitation to explore a new food can communicate support and confidence.
People with ARFID may already feel frustrated by their eating challenges. They may want to eat more foods but feel unable to do so because of anxiety, sensory discomfort, or fear. Others may not yet understand why working toward food variety or adequate intake is important for their health.
When we approach someone with impatience, we risk increasing their distress and making food-related experiences more difficult.
Instead of assuming someone is being stubborn, difficult, or unwilling to cooperate, consider what might be happening beneath the surface.
Could they be experiencing intense anxiety? Is the texture overwhelming? Are they afraid of choking or becoming sick? Do they have the skills and support they need to manage the experience?
Encouragement should communicate, “I believe you can work through this, and I'm here to support you,” rather than, “This shouldn't be so hard.”

3. Make Sure There Is a Purpose Behind Trying a New Food
There is an important difference between asking someone with ARFID to try a food because it is expected in a social situation and encouraging food exploration as part of a larger recovery goal.
At a family gathering, the goal behind “just try it” might simply be to encourage polite behavior or persuade a child to eat something different. Even when the intention is well-meaning, the request may not be appropriate for that moment.
In ARFID treatment, however, trying a new food can be part of a broader plan to improve nutritional adequacy, increase food variety, reduce food-related fear, or work toward greater flexibility and independence with eating.
For example, someone with ARFID may be working with a registered dietitian and therapist to increase their intake, incorporate additional food groups, reduce reliance on nutritional supplements when appropriate, or gradually expand the foods they can comfortably eat.
In this setting, food exploration has a purpose connected to the individual's health and well-being.
We also need to recognize that avoiding scary experiences is a normal human response. Why step toward something unfamiliar when stepping away feels safer?
For someone with ARFID, avoidance may provide immediate relief while making it harder to meet nutritional needs or participate in everyday experiences involving food.
Supportive treatment helps individuals work toward meaningful goals while acknowledging that the process can be uncomfortable.
Sometimes, people need someone alongside them to offer encouragement, help them manage distress, and remind them why taking that next step matters.
4. Make Sure the Person Has the Skills Needed to Try
Imagine someone asking you to jump out of an airplane.
You might respond, “Absolutely not!”
But what if the situation changed? What if someone taught you how a parachute works, helped you understand the process, answered your questions, and allowed you to take small steps toward feeling prepared?
The experience might become more manageable.
Trying new foods with ARFID can work in a similar way.
Before asking someone to try a challenging food, we need to consider whether they have the skills and support needed to manage the experience.
Depending on the individual, these skills may include:
Recognizing and managing anxiety around unfamiliar foods.
Practicing breathing, grounding, or other coping strategies.
Exploring sensory characteristics such as smell, texture, temperature, and appearance.
Learning how to approach food in gradual, manageable steps.
Understanding the difference between feeling anxious about a food and being in actual danger.
Practicing flexibility and learning how to respond when an experience feels uncomfortable.
For some individuals, the process may begin with looking at a food, having it nearby, touching it, or smelling it. Others may be ready to progress toward tasting a small amount.
There is no single sequence that works for everyone.
This is why a relative unexpectedly saying, “Here, try this!” may be unhelpful. They may not know what preparation the individual needs, which foods fit their current treatment goals, or what strategies the person can use to manage their response.
Food exposure should be individualized and appropriately supported, not based on the assumption that everyone is ready to take the same step.
5. Choose the Right Setting and Provide the Right Support
People with ARFID can learn to approach unfamiliar foods and expand their food variety. However, the setting, timing, and support available can make a meaningful difference.
For some individuals, trying a new food may be easier in a familiar environment with a trusted caregiver or treatment provider. For others, a structured therapeutic activity may help them focus on their goals without the added pressure of a family gathering or public meal.
It is also important to understand that motivation can be complicated.
Someone may recognize that eating more foods could benefit their health but still feel overwhelmed by the prospect of trying something unfamiliar. Another person may not yet understand why treatment goals matter or may have difficulty connecting those goals to their own life.
Rather than assuming a person simply does not want to recover, we can help them understand the purpose of treatment and identify meaningful reasons to work toward change.
Think about someone recovering from an injury who needs to gradually begin walking again. The process may be uncomfortable, but the person receives guidance, appropriate support, and manageable steps toward a larger goal.
ARFID recovery also involves working toward difficult goals with the right preparation and support.
A supportive approach might sound like this:
“I imagine this feels hard and scary. The food is unfamiliar, and you're worried you won't like it or that it will feel disgusting. We've practiced some strategies to help you manage those feelings, and I'm here with you. Let's explore this food in a way that feels manageable and talk about what you notice.”
The goal is not to pretend that trying a new food is easy. It is to acknowledge the difficulty while helping the individual build confidence and skills.
How Can You Encourage Someone With ARFID to Try New Foods?
If you are a parent, caregiver, or clinician supporting someone with ARFID, you do not necessarily need to avoid encouraging new foods altogether. Instead, focus on making food exploration purposeful, individualized, and supportive.
Consider these strategies:
Learn about ARFID. Understand how sensory sensitivities, fear, anxiety, and low interest in food can affect eating.
Collaborate on goals. Help the individual understand why working toward nutritional adequacy, food variety, or greater flexibility may matter to them.
Break the process into smaller steps. Depending on the person's needs, food exploration may begin with looking, touching, smelling, or tasting.
Practice coping skills. Help the individual develop strategies to manage anxiety and discomfort before and during food exploration.
Choose the right time and place. Avoid turning unexpected social meals into opportunities for pressure or confrontation.
Offer encouragement without shame. Recognize effort, curiosity, and willingness to practice rather than judging the amount eaten.
Work with an ARFID-informed treatment team. A registered dietitian and appropriately qualified mental health professional can help individualize food exposure and recovery goals.
Remember that progress does not always mean eating an entire serving of a new food. Depending on the person's treatment plan, progress may involve becoming more comfortable around a food, exploring its sensory characteristics, or practicing a previously difficult step.
The goal is to support meaningful recovery, not to turn every meal into a test.
So, Should You Tell Someone With ARFID to “Just Try It”?
Our answer is that we should not automatically rule out encouraging someone with ARFID to try a new food. Trying foods can be an important part of recovery, and avoiding every challenging food experience may make it more difficult to work toward nutritional and functional goals.
However, encouraging someone to try a food is different from expecting them to do it without preparation, understanding, or support.
Before asking someone with ARFID to try something new, consider the individual, the long-term goal, the steps needed to reach that goal, and the skills required to manage the experience.
Think about the setting, timing, and support that will help create a safe and productive opportunity for food exploration.
Most importantly, recognize that a person's initial reaction does not necessarily tell us what they will be capable of achieving with appropriate treatment and support.
We can give people the grace to feel scared while also helping them take meaningful steps forward.
We can acknowledge that something is hard without deciding it is impossible.
And we can communicate confidence in someone's ability to grow without dismissing what they are experiencing.
ARFID recovery is not about forcing someone to eat a food. It is about helping them build the skills, confidence, and flexibility to work toward a healthier, less restrictive relationship with food.
Sometimes, trying a new food is the next step. The difference lies in how we help someone get there.




Comments